A Hockey Alliance exclusive by Ron Jones
We asked our readers along with sites from the Hockey
Alliance to rank the forwards currently in the NHL and come up
with their very own Top 10 list. Like last year we received a wide
array of responses from a number of people and we have tabulated all
the votes to come up with a definitive Top 10 list.
In all there were 48 different players, 11 more than last year,
that garnered at least one vote. However, only the Colorado
Avalanche's Peter Forsberg made it on to every voter's list.
Mats Sundin (7th) and Paul Kariya (9th) were bumped off the list and
replaced by Boston's Joe Thornton and Atlanta's Dany Heatley.
Scoring System:
Each first place vote was awarded with 10 points, second place vote
with nine points, third place vote with eight points and so on
Drum roll please
The Top 10 Forwards in the NHL as voted by the readers and staff of
McKeen's Hockey for 2003 are:
1st Place Peter Forsberg
Colorado
Avalanche (828 points)
As I began adding up the votes it became clear early on that the
race for first was a one horse race as Peter Forsberg threatened to
lap his peers. He was also the only player to be on every voters'
ballot. The majority of votes he received were for first place, and
the worst vote he had was for 9th.
Your Comments:
"
tough as a nail, scoring title will
always be his if healthy and playing ..." and "
Great combination
of skill and size, there's a reason he won the Hart
"
2nd Place Joe Thornton
Boston Bruins (524
points)
One of three players to surpass 500 points, which is even a bigger
accomplishment considering that last season Thornton finished in a
dissapointing 14th place. He only received five first place votes,
however, he was left off of far fewer ballots than his nearest
competitor.
Your Comments:
"
Turning into what Lindros might have
been with a level head
" and "
will be #1 on this list very soon
and may possibly be better than Forsberg in the long run, he's just
not there yet
"
3rd Place Mario Lemieux
Pittsburgh Penguins
(510 points)
Climbed three spots to third place. Had 21 first place votes, but
was left off of 23 ballots to hurt his chances at passing Joe
Thornton for second spot. Still, all in all a remarkable
achievement for a player that is on a horrible team and that could
easily be enjoying his retirement years.
Your Comments:
"
Doesn't matter that he plays on an
AHL team
" and "
the best player to ever play the game
"
4th Place Markus Naslund
Vancouver Canucks
(454 points)
Moved up six spots and was the only player not in the top 3 to reach
400 points. Like last season, few people had anything negative to
say, but there was a perception that he wouldn't be as good without
Bertuzzi and vice versa.
Your Comments:
"
Awesome offensive skills, great
shot, great vision
" and "
ice water in his veins. Nothing (short
of a team-wide collapse) can stop him from showing up on the
scoresheet. He seems to do it almost unconsciously
"
5th Place Joe Sakic
Colorado Avalanche (399
points)
Fell three spots to fifth place overall, but still impressed five
voters enough to be first on their list. It is quite possible that
playing in only 58 games last season had a negative impact on his
rankings.
Your Comments:
"
He used to be better, but still
puts up the numbers and is always dangerous when on the ice)
"
and "
teammate Peter may have size and youth on his side, but
captain Joe holds everything together. Colorado (and Team Canada
for that matter) has accomplished nothing with him watching in
street clothes
"
6th Place Mike Modano
Dallas Stars (367 points)
It seems as Modano gets older more people are starting to see how
good he really is and give him the credit he is due. He climbed two
spots in the rankings from last year, even though he only had one
first place vote. Last player on the list to eclipse the 300 point
mark.
Your Comments:
"
I thought he was good, but the more
I watch him, the better he is
" and "
More than just a pretty
face, probably the most consistent player in the game right now
(consistently good that is)
"
7th Place Jaromir Jagr
Washington Capitals
(268 points)
His days in Washington have not been kind to him and some will argue
that they haven't been that great for the Capitals either! His
stock dropped amongst our readers four spots from last year. Not
that long ago he would have been first or second, but with only one
first place vote and a number of no-votes it is not surprising that
he was only seventh.
Your Comments:
"
should be higher but seems to have
lost some heart, if he finds it again then he's holding down the no.
3 spot
" and "
Write this great off at your peril
"
8th Place Todd Bertuzzi
Vancouver Canucks
(259 points)
He had a career year once again producing personal bests in goals,
assists and points, however, some fans felt he wouldn't be as good
without Naslund as well as his poorer than expected play in the
playoffs combined to drop his rankings from 5th spot last season to
8th overall.
Your Comments:
"
plays with heart emotion and brute
strength has soft hands and can score. You can teach anyone to score
goals and make plays and if they have the god given talent the will
excel in this game but, 6-4, 245 try and teach that!
" and "
a
bully that can score too, He is the real deal
"
9th Place Jarome Iginla
Calgary Flames (246
points)
For awhile it looked as if voters might hold his "bad" season
against him, but he was able to rally enough votes and not fall all
the way off our list. Iginla didn't have one first place vote, but
did get a number of second to sizth place votes helped offset the no-
votes.
Your Comments:
"
has little support in Calgary, but
will be back this upcoming season
" and "
ranked as high as he is
(on my list) for the plain fact that compared to the others on this
list Jarome doesn't have the talent beside him like the others
"
10th Place Dany Heatley
Atlanta Thrashers
(207 points)
Excellent All-Star performance may have vaulted him on to the list,
even then he probably is still a bit of a secret having to ply his
trade in that hockey hotbed in Georgia. Heatley actually did have
one first place ranking, but generally he garnered votes in and
around the 7th to 10th range.
Your Comments:
"
With him and Kovalchuk, the
Thrashers have a chance at the playoffs
" and "
in a couple years,
could be number 1
"
The rest of the forwards that received votes in order
were:
Sergei Fedorov, Ana (180 points)
Marian Hossa, Ott (127 pts)
Mats Sundin, Tor (55 pts)
Milan Hejduk, Col (49 pts)
Marian Gaborik, Min (48 pts)
Pavol Demitra, StL (37 pts)
Steve Yzerman, Det (56 pts)
Paul Kariya, Col (34 pts)
Alexei Kovalev, NYR (31 pts)
Daniel Alfredsson, Ott (30 pts)
Alex Mogilny, Tor (26 pts)
Doug Weight, StL (22 pts)
Zigmund Palffy, LA (20 pts)
Jason Allison, LA (13 pts)
Vincent Lecavalier, TB (13 pts)
Martin Straka, Pit (12 pts)
Martin St. Louis, TB (10 pts)
Brett Hull, Det (10 pts)
Glen Murray, Bos (9 pts)
John Madden, NJ (9 pts)
Keith Tkachuk, StL (9 pts)
Teemu Selanne, Col (8 pts)
Ilya Kovalchuk, Atl (5 pts)
Eric Lindros, NYR (2 pts)
Forwards that received only one vote:
Saku Koivu (mtl), Bill Guerin (dal), Dave Andreychuk (tb), Jeremy
Roenick (phi), Pavel Bure (nyr), Ron Francis (car), Jamie
Langenbrunner (nj), Martin Havlat (ott), Brendan Shanahan (det),
Miroslav Satan (buf), Jere Lehtinen (dal), Peter Bondra (wsh), Luc
Robitaille (la) and Stephane Yelle (cgy).
Amongst the forwards that had votes last year, but didn't get
any this year are:
Patrik Elias (nj)
Alexei Yashin (nyi)
Owen Nolan (tor)
Gary Roberts (tor)
Craig Conroy (cgy)
Mike Peca (nyi)
Ryan Smyth (edm)
Simon Gagne (phi)
Jeff O'Neill (car)
Special thanks to the following sites (hope I didn't forget
anybody):
TheFeeder,
SabreFans.com,
Orange and
Black,
SensNetwork.com,
Doyoubleedblue.com, CoyotesCorner.net and Calgary
Puck.
© 2003 ThePredatorsReport.com
The Predators Report is a non-profit fansite covering the Nashville Predators. It is not affiliated with the Nashville Predators or the NHL. All logos are property of the NHL.